A Wake Up Call

How Westerners and Vietnamese differ on the method of putting their children to bed

Text by Michael Arnold
Image by Quinn Ryan Mattingly

If there’s anything that’s a universal heart-warmer, it’s the sight of a sleeping kid snuggled up warmly beneath the blankets. No grumpy parent can resist that completely relaxed and totally intent expression of their own child absorbed in sleep; the only thing capable of making us forget the total chaos they’re capable of when they’re awake.

Of course, it’s supposed to be the parent’s task to get them into that state in the first place and to wake them up again at the appropriate time – something that takes far more skill than you might think. My daughter, quite infuriatingly, just doesn’t enjoy sleep at all – far too interested in every ambient noise and the shifting lights on the ceiling from passing bikes outside, she requires a great deal of cajoling – bordering on pleading – just to get her to keep her head flat on the pillow. As soon as the gathering morning glow touches the curtains, she’s up again, just in time to remind me to feel guilty for heading off to work.

Of course, not every kid’s like mine, but it does lead me to wonder – do the Vietnamese deal with this problem any better than I do? Are Vietnamese methods traditionally tender or something more brutal?

Single mother Minh Anh has long since given up on proper bedtimes for her young son who, despite having a bedroom with most things a kid should want, insists on sharing a bed with his mom. “Minh Viet’s a late sleeper,” she says. “He’ll watch TV until the broadcasting finishes at around 11 and there’s nothing left to see. I usually have to work late on my laptop anyway, and inevitably I’ll turn around to find he’s simply switched off.”

The late bedtimes are a problem for a kid whose international school classes start at 7.30am, but Minh Anh doesn’t have to face this struggle alone. “His father calls him every morning at 6.30am. I hold my phone to his ear so that he can hear his Dad’s voice. He likes that, but it doesn’t get him out of bed – I usually turn on Cartoon Network and slowly raise the volume until his natural curiosity to watch what’s happening takes over.”

“The one thing that always gets him up is if I tell him he’s going to make me late. He just loves me enough not to want to cause me any trouble. He gets to school on time.”

A Stronger Attitude

If Vietnamese sleep training is essentially a gentle science, it’s one that failed Amy Vu, whose daughter Sofia’s troubled sleep habits only improved after leaving Ho Chi Minh City and going abroad.

“I was breastfeeding until she was 18 months old,” she says. “At the time, she kept waking up at night, and I thought I had to feed her so she could get back to sleep. The situation got worse and worse – we were both very tired, and neither of us slept well.”

After two months in New Zealand, however, Amy encountered a nurse who advised her to stop feeding her daughter at night. “She cried for three nights consecutively, and I wasn’t allowed to touch her or say anything to her. I just let her cry until she got too tired and went back to sleep. However, it worked perfectly after the third night; she cried less and stopped completely on the fourth.”

“Now she sleeps very deeply through the night. I’m so grateful to that nurse – most of the Vietnamese advice I received was focused on her need to eat rather than sleep,” Amy adds. “Vietnamese people seem to nurture their kids too much. We’re not strong enough to teach babies to be independent. We’re too scared to hear babies crying and compromise too easily. Westerners are much stronger in their training attitudes. They gave me clear, confident instructions – exactly what new mums need.”

Local restaurateur and expat father Scott Marquis made similar moves in training his daughter to do without a night feed despite local attitudes, but then he’s got it easy: “Zoey is a great sleeper, and has been since she was born.” That being said, Zoey’s situation is a little different from most kids, in that with both parents working nights, she tends to sleep their hours too.

Regular napping keeps Zoey fresh. “On a normal day she naps twice, from around 12pm-1pm till she wakes up, and then again in the early evening before she comes to visit us at the restaurant. We try to put her down between 10pm-11pm, but it doesn’t always work” he laughs. Wake-up times are similarly effortless: “We just let her sleep until she wakes up. If we have to take her out before she’s awake, it’s no problem. She just gets a little cranky because we didn’t lie around in bed and play with her for awhile.”

What surprises Scott most is that Zoey’s Vietnamese grandmother seems to take their Western approach in stride. Zoey doesn’t co-sleep with her parents, unlike most Vietnamese children, and sleeps in fully air-conditioned rooms – habits that expats often report cause heated debates with their Vietnamese in-laws, who are concerned that Western child rearing techniques buck time-tested traditions.

“Duc’s mom has been really good about doing things our way when we’re around. She follows our ‘no sweet milk or sugar’ rule, and we let her put a hat on Zoey no matter how hot it is when she takes her outside,” explains Scott. “It might be that Zoey is so smart, alert, happy, and active that Grandma just doesn’t question us about everything.”

Share this story, choose your platform!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on tumblr
Share on google
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on vk
Share on email
About the author:

2 thoughts on “A Wake Up Call”

  1. I was suggested this web site by my cousin.
    I am not sure whether this post is written by him as no
    one else know such detailed about my problem. You are amazing!


Leave a Comment

7 Helpful Tips for Moms Returning to Work

Returning to work is a challenge for most new moms. Besides leaving your little one alone for the first time, you also need to face going back to your work routine. Many doubts can start popping in your mind. Thoughts such as “Can I do this?”, “Will my child be okay without me?”, “Will I

Read More »

Deep Rejuvenation

A visit to Thao Dien’s traditional Thai spa Leelawadee provides an array of therapeutic treatments sure to leave you feeling revitalized Leelawadee Thai Therapy Thao Dien was opened a few years ago at 5/19 Duong 64 in Thao Dien by Mimi Noita, a native of Thailand with a desire to bring traditional Thai massage therapy

Read More »

Using Technology to Help You Take Care of Your Aging Parents

Technology has made life easy by offering solutions to pretty everything that we need. With just an app, you can open your door even if you are far from home. With thermostats, you can save massive amounts of electricity since they adjust the house temperature throughout the day. The caregiving sector has not been left

Read More »

Escapist Therapy

How reading science fiction can build resilience in kids Young people who are hooked on watching fantasy or reading science fiction may be on to something. Contrary to a common misperception that reading this genre is an unworthy practice, reading science fiction and fantasy may help young people cope, especially with the stress and anxiety

Read More »

Demystifying Coronavirus

Read more on what we know about COVID-19 including understanding the disease and addressing some of the fears and concerns Coronaviruses are a large family of viruses that infect mostly animals, although a few of them have spread to humans as well. The infections they cause can range from mild to severe. The most common

Read More »

108 Sun Salutations Challenge

Celebrating spring equinox while also giving back to the local community The sun sits low in the sky, the morning air is still cool. People begin to arrive, yoga mats over their shoulders, hair still wet from the shower and water bottles or coffee cups in their hands. An altar is set up at the

Read More »