Saigon’s Visual Identity, Yesterday to Today

Saigon is expanding at breakneck speed. In order to learn more about what might happen, what will happen, and what should happen, Oi spoke with a number of informed, invested, and expert sources on Saigon’s progress, development and identity.

Our expert panel:

Andrew Currie
Co-Founder & Managing Director of
OUT-2 Design & Workplace-Asia

Archie Pizzini
Design Principal
HTA+pizzini In-Situ Architects

Hoanh Tran
Design Principal
HTA+pizzini In-Situ Architects

Lam Dang
Legal Consultant

Matthew Young

Mel Schenk

Tim Doling

Hoanh: The identity of Saigon is made up of an accumulation of many different layers, many different versions of one city. The Saigon we know is actually not very old; it begins with the French colonial architecture largely because what was built before was built from wood and did not last or was razed by French urban planners. So we have layers of early and late French colonial, and generally speaking, these buildings have a beautiful, human scale, and well adapted to the climate.

Mel: The French colonial architecture comes out of an agricultural age, when economies and their buildings were designed around agricultural production. The modernist era that followed comes out of the industrial age. From Art Deco to Modernism, it still has links to French architecture, namely Le Corbusier, but it’s on a mass production scale and a complete departure from the agricultural identity. Local architects took the new concepts and made them their own; the buildings from this period are truly Vietnamese modernism – from the public facilities down to the shophouses.

IMG_0031 (OiVietNam-3N)

Also, unlike Thailand and Cambodia, where many buildings took their architectural instruction from religion, with the exception of Hue and the Cham areas, most of Vietnamese architecture was and remains very eclectic, and very present and future oriented.

Matthew: The French colonial architecture gets the most attention today. Why is it more important than what came before or after this period? It was a period of 70 years or so, but it seems to represent or relate to a notion of affluence, or succeeding to the international stage. Conversely, some of the Soviet architecture that came later is very interesting from an architectural point of view, but it rarely gets attention because it is tied to a different and less well-regarded time.

Andrew: There is such nostalgia for the French style that even up to ten years ago, when clients would say they wanted a contemporary Vietnamese building, what they really meant was they wanted French colonial. It is changing now, with the younger local architects coming onto the scene wanting something more youthful and exuberant, and having seen what others are building around the world.

Archie: Many colonial buildings were replaced by modernist buildings during the building boom of the 1960s and 1970s. At the time, Saigon was a small city, low to the ground, and visually, it welcomed individual interpretation. Modernist architecture actually facilitated this. The new modernist buildings of the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s made great use of space and shade and ventilation – this was all pre-air-conditioning – and Saigon’s visual identity began to separate from some other parts of Vietnam.

IMG_4254 (OiVietNam-3N)

Matthew: As it should have. Vietnam has different topography, weather, ethnicities and each influences the types of structures in a particular area. Hanoi has four seasons, Saigon barely has two; they should differ.

Archie: After 1975 there was still a period of informal growth. In spite of economic constraints, buildings grew room by room, with modest, individual spaces added onto the French and American buildings. It was a very organic architectural period, very ad-hoc, very personal. For the larger projects, there was the importation of Soviet style architecture.

Mel: As Saigon settled into peace, aspirations rose. From temporary shelters to single story homes and then as families grew, so did the height of the home. The point being, people did not move, they simply added on and added up. The basic structure, which still dominates today, was four meters by ten or twenty. It is an efficient structure, with no need for hallways, and reflects the innate sense of design the Vietnamese have. The personality was in the façade and the interior design.

IMG_3742 (OiVietNam-3N)

Matthew: The pre- Doi Moiarchitecture you see in Saigon is almost hard to call modernist. The ideals behind modernist architecture – mass production, age of machinery – don’t represent what was being built. Saigon’s modernism is so bespoke, so personal, and there is so much exploration of form, that it almost reminds me more of the Arts & Crafts style that blended being modern with being distinct.

Andrew: These tube houses, four meters by 20 or 30, didn’t allow for light on the sides. Unlike similar typologies in the region, modern Vietnamese tube houses gave little thought to the incorporation of courtyards and other open spaces, everything was covered so as to show it was completely used space and therefore more valuable if ever the property was reclaimed. The light came down the center around the staircase, which works for up to five stories. You could make the argument that the tube house is the most representative Saigonese building, because local architects have been redesigning this same type of rectangle over and over and therefore have become experts in its design and potential. They’re still interpreting it, improving it, keeping it relevant and it will continue to be a key part of the visual landscape of Saigon.

Hoanh: So you had around 200 years of layering, basically up until the present, post Doi Moi period. This is the identity of Saigon: a fabric of two centuries worth of cultures, styles, improvisations and local interpretations, all woven into a completely unique visual narrative.

IMG_0069 (OiVietNam-3N)

For other articles on this series, click here.


Share this story, choose your platform!

About the author:

Leave a Comment

5 Examples of Wrongful Termination Explained

Being fired from work can be a traumatic experience for anyone. However, if it has been done illegally it’s even more overwhelming. There are many instances where letting go of an employee is completely valid. But, if you have been unfairly dismissed without a reason – legal action can be taken.  To help you understand

Read More »

Six Signs That Indicate Your Partner Is Micro-Cheating On You

Relationship experts say that “clearly defining your boundaries can set a happy and healthy relationship with your partners.” However, we may need to understand when these boundaries go too far off the line and create a rift in our relationship. Every relationship has little white lies or harmless secrets that partners keep from each other. Not

Read More »

How Carpet Cleaning Enhances Carpet’s life and Value?

Carpet cleaning can be painstaking when you have a large house and many carpets. With that in mind, it is easy to understand why people require the services of professional carpet cleaning companies that can quickly clean up your messes. However, carpets are not the only things you might need to clean up. When it

Read More »

The States That Have Legalized Marijuana So Far 2021

Are you interested in the legalization status of marijuana, especially in the United States, and want to learn more? Do you want to know where in the United States you could visit and still be able to smoke a joint legally? The legalization of marijuana has been a hot topic in the United States for

Read More »

Understanding A Hoarder: Why Can’t They Throw Anything Away?

To provide an understanding and the process of hoarding, we must first understand its definition. Hoarding is defined as a single-minded urge of collecting and safekeeping unwanted items in great numbers. Most of the people afflicted with hoarding disorder find it hard to throw away items. A hoarder desires to save items that they know

Read More »

Vietnam War Student Protests

Where did the student movement begin? The US airplanes started bombing North Vietnam in February 1965 after North Vietnamese submarines invaded 2 US ships at the Gulf of Tonkin. President Lyndon B Johnson commanded the revenge attacks blasting armed targets in North Vietnam. There were some criticisms about how the government was battling the self-governing

Read More »